Some rivalries are remembered because two champions traded victories.
Others are remembered because one horse seemed almost impossible to beat, while another refused to stop trying.
For a remarkable stretch of Japanese horse racing at the beginning of the 21st century, T.M. Opera O stood at the center of the sport. He won race after race, including every one of his eight starts in 2000. The Tenno Sho. The Takarazuka Kinen. The Japan Cup. The Arima Kinen. Wherever the biggest prizes were waiting, he seemed to find a way to take them.
And very often, the horse immediately behind him was the same one.
Meisho Doto.
Again and again, Doto challenged the champion. Again and again, he finished second.
Five times in Grade 1 races, T.M. Opera O defeated Meisho Doto with Doto finishing directly behind him.
It would have been easy for history to remember Doto simply as the horse who could not beat the king.
But that is not how his story ended.
An Irish-Bred Horse Bound for Japan
Meisho Doto was foaled in Ireland on March 25, 1996. He was bred by P. Hardy and eventually raced in Japan for owner Yoshio Matsumoto under trainer Isao Yasuda.
His pedigree was thoroughly international.
His sire, Bigstone, was a son of Last Tycoon, while his dam Princess Reema was a daughter of Affirmed, the great American champion who captured the U.S. Triple Crown in 1978.
Meisho Doto therefore arrived in Japanese racing with European and American influences in his pedigree, but his reputation would be built almost entirely on Japanese turf.
It did not happen quickly.
A Career That Began Without Fanfare
Meisho Doto made his racing debut in January 1999.
He was already three years old by Japanese racing age, yet he was nowhere near the Classic conversation that spring. While horses such as T.M. Opera O, Admire Vega and Narita Top Road were fighting through the Satsuki Sho, Japanese Derby and Kikuka Sho, Doto was progressing through ordinary races.
He even recorded his first victory on dirt.
There was little reason at that stage to imagine that this late-developing horse would soon become one of the central figures of his generation.
But Doto kept improving.
By the autumn of 1999 he was winning on turf, and by early 2000 he had reached graded-stakes company.
His transformation was about to accelerate.
The Rise of Meisho Doto
In March 2000, Meisho Doto won the Chukyo Kinen over 2000 meters.
It was his first graded victory.
He followed it with victory in the Metropolitan Stakes and then won the Kinko Sho in May.
A horse who had spent the previous year climbing quietly through the ranks was suddenly ready for Grade 1 competition.
His first major test came in the Takarazuka Kinen at Hanshin.
Waiting for him was T.M. Opera O.
Opera O had already won the Satsuki Sho as a three-year-old and had developed into a formidable older horse. In the spring of 2000, he won the Kyoto Kinen, Hanshin Daishoten and Tenno Sho (Spring).
Meisho Doto entered the Takarazuka Kinen as a rising challenger.
He nearly won.
Doto fought to the finish, but Opera O caught him and defeated him by a neck.
It was the beginning of one of the most persistent rivalries in modern Japanese racing.
The Champion and the Challenger
After the Takarazuka Kinen, Meisho Doto continued to prove that his emergence was no accident.
He won the All Comers at Nakayama in September and went to the Tenno Sho (Autumn) as one of the leading contenders.
Again, T.M. Opera O was there.
Again, Opera O won.
Again, Meisho Doto finished second.
The margin was 2 1/2 lengths.
Next came the Japan Cup at Tokyo, where international opposition joined Japan's best horses.
Fantastic Light represented Godolphin. Other accomplished runners came from overseas. But when the race reached its decisive moment, the familiar Japanese pair were there again.
T.M. Opera O won.
Meisho Doto finished second.
This time the official record showed no time difference between them.
Doto had come agonizingly close.
Then came the Arima Kinen.
Another Heartbreak in the Arima Kinen
The 2000 Arima Kinen became one of T.M. Opera O's most famous victories.
Opera O encountered traffic and appeared to be in serious trouble as the field entered the final stages.
Meisho Doto was in position to capitalize.
For a few moments, it seemed that this might finally be his chance.
But Opera O found room.
The champion surged through and reached the finish first.
Meisho Doto was second again.
The margin was tiny. Official records again gave both horses the same finishing time of 2:34.1.
For Doto, it completed an extraordinary season.
He had become one of the best older horses in Japan. He had won three graded stakes during the year and finished second in three consecutive autumn Grade 1 races.
Yet every time he stood on the edge of the biggest victory, the same horse was waiting in front of him.
T.M. Opera O finished 2000 unbeaten in eight starts and was named Japan's Horse of the Year.
Meisho Doto had become the champion's shadow.
One More Defeat
The new season began with an important sign.
In March 2001, Meisho Doto won the Nikkei Sho over 2500 meters at Nakayama.
He then went to Kyoto for the Tenno Sho (Spring), the great 3200-meter test of Japanese staying ability.
Once more, T.M. Opera O stood between Doto and a Grade 1 title.
Opera O won the race in 3:16.2.
Meisho Doto finished second.
It was now the fifth time that Doto had finished directly behind T.M. Opera O in a Grade 1 race.
Five times.
2000 Takarazuka Kinen.
2000 Tenno Sho (Autumn).
2000 Japan Cup.
2000 Arima Kinen.
2001 Tenno Sho (Spring).
For another horse, that sequence might have become the definition of his career.
Meisho Doto still had one more chance.
June 24, 2001
The scene was Hanshin Racecourse.
The race was the Takarazuka Kinen.
One year earlier, this had been the race in which T.M. Opera O first defeated Meisho Doto in a Grade 1.
Now they returned.
Opera O was the favorite.
Doto was the second choice.
There were other accomplished horses in the field, including Stay Gold and Air Shakur, but the central question was familiar.
Could anyone defeat T.M. Opera O?
More specifically, could Meisho Doto finally do it?
The Race He Had Been Chasing
Meisho Doto raced prominently under his regular jockey Yasuhiko Yasuda.
As the field moved toward the final turn, Doto was already close to the leaders and ready to make his move.
He accelerated into the straight and took command.
Behind him, T.M. Opera O began his challenge.
This was the moment Japanese racing fans had seen repeatedly.
Doto in front.
Opera O coming after him.
In the previous year's Takarazuka Kinen, Opera O had caught him.
This time, Doto did not surrender the lead.
He reached the finish in 2:11.7.
T.M. Opera O finished second in 2:11.9.
The margin was 1 1/4 lengths.
After so many defeats, Meisho Doto had finally beaten him in a Grade 1.
The horse who had spent a year finishing behind the champion was now a Grade 1 winner himself.
Why the Victory Meant So Much
In isolation, winning the Takarazuka Kinen would have been enough to make Meisho Doto an important racehorse.
But the meaning of the victory comes from everything that preceded it.
Doto had not avoided Opera O.
He had repeatedly faced him in Japan's greatest races.
He had lost by a neck.
He had lost by margins so small that the official times were identical.
He had finished second in the Tenno Sho, Japan Cup, Arima Kinen and another Tenno Sho.
And he returned again.
The 2001 Takarazuka Kinen did not erase those defeats.
It transformed them.
Without the five Grade 1 runner-up finishes, the victory would simply have been a major win.
Because of them, it became the climax of a rivalry.
The Rivalry in Numbers
Meisho Doto and T.M. Opera O met nine times during their racing careers.
Opera O finished ahead in seven of those meetings. Doto finished ahead twice.
Yet the raw score does not fully describe how closely connected their careers became.
According to Japan's retired-racehorse records, in eight of their nine meetings the two horses finished only one position apart.
They were constantly together at the decisive end of major races.
JRA later produced an official memorial feature devoted specifically to their rivalry, describing their repeated battles across the turn of the century.
That is an unusual distinction.
Meisho Doto was not merely another horse defeated by T.M. Opera O.
He was the opponent who kept returning.
When a New Generation Arrived
The Takarazuka Kinen victory was the peak of Meisho Doto's career, but Japanese racing was already beginning to change.
He returned in the autumn of 2001 for the Tenno Sho (Autumn).
This time neither Doto nor Opera O won.
Agnes Digital defeated them, with T.M. Opera O second and Meisho Doto third.
The Japan Cup brought another changing of the guard. Three-year-old Japanese Derby winner Jungle Pocket won, Opera O finished second, and Doto was fifth.
In the Arima Kinen, Manhattan Cafe defeated American Boss, To the Victory and Meisho Doto. Opera O finished fifth.
The era in which Opera O and Doto had dominated Japan's major middle- and long-distance races was ending.
After the 2001 season, both horses retired.
Appropriately, even retirement did not immediately separate them.
Together Beyond the Racetrack
T.M. Opera O and Meisho Doto took part in a joint retirement ceremony and were transported together to East Stud, where both began stallion careers.
It was a fitting final image for two horses whose racing lives had become so closely linked.
As a stallion, Meisho Doto did not reproduce his own top-level racing success through a major JRA Grade 1 winner.
JBIS records list horses such as Rising Wave and Shigeru Takk among his better offspring, while Shine finished second in the 2010 Shinzan Kinen.
His stud career therefore never transformed his historical reputation.
His identity remained tied most strongly to what he had done on the racecourse.
And, inevitably, to T.M. Opera O.
A Different Kind of Fame in Retirement
Meisho Doto's story did not disappear when his breeding career ended.
He became a retired racehorse supported through Japan's retirement-horse community and developed another following entirely separate from his racing record.
Fans who remembered the relentless Grade 1 challenger were joined by younger fans who encountered him as an elderly retired horse.
His gentle appearance and life after racing attracted affection both in Japan and overseas.
That second life has helped introduce a new generation to the races that made him famous.
For some younger international fans, the process works in reverse: they first discover the retired Meisho Doto, then learn that the friendly old horse they are watching once spent two seasons repeatedly challenging one of the greatest champions in Japanese racing history.
And then they discover the 2001 Takarazuka Kinen.
More Than a Runner-Up
Meisho Doto retired with 27 starts, 10 victories, eight seconds and two thirds, earning more than 921 million yen.
He won five graded races.
Only one was a Grade 1.
But reducing his career to the number "one" misses almost everything that made him important.
His story is about proximity to greatness.
He was good enough to reach the same great races as T.M. Opera O again and again.
Good enough to challenge him.
Good enough to finish second five times at Grade 1 level.
And eventually, good enough to beat him.
There are champions whose careers seem inevitable in retrospect.
Meisho Doto's career feels different.
His greatest moment mattered precisely because failure had come first.
Not once.
Not twice.
Again and again.
That is why the 2001 Takarazuka Kinen remains the perfect ending to the central chapter of his racing life.
For more than a year, Meisho Doto chased T.M. Opera O through the biggest races in Japanese horse racing.
He kept finding the champion in front of him.
Until one afternoon at Hanshin, he finally looked back and found the champion behind.
No comments:
Post a Comment