Bubble Gum Fellow spent 1997 within a neck of winning two more championships. Marvelous Sunday beat him by that margin in the Takarazuka Kinen; Air Groove did the same in the autumn Tenno Sho. He then finished third in the Japan Cup. Across five appearances that year he won twice and never finished outside the first three. For a horse often introduced through a single pioneering victory at three, the following season supplies an equally important measure of his place among Japan's best.
The three championship defeats also resist a simple explanation. They came over 2,200, 2,000 and 2,400 metres, against different winners, with different jockeys riding Bubble Gum Fellow. His story runs through the changing opportunities for a young middle-distance horse, then through the competition required to remain near the top. The most revealing comparison is between the colt who beat established champions in October 1996 and the older horse who kept meeting new ones in 1997.
Two necks in the older-horse division
At Hanshin on 6 July 1997, Masayoshi Ebina rode Bubble Gum Fellow against Marvelous Sunday in the Takarazuka Kinen. Both were sons of Sunday Silence. Marvelous Sunday was favourite, Bubble Gum Fellow third choice, with the latter's stablemate Taiki Blizzard between them in the betting. The finish gave Marvelous Sunday his championship by a neck, both principals receiving 2:11.9 on firm turf. Dance Partner was another length and a quarter behind the runner-up.
The corner order gives that narrow defeat a useful shape. Bubble Gum Fellow was in the middle group early and among the leaders at the final bend; Marvelous Sunday had been farther back. Ebina's horse had already worked his way into the contest when the eventual winner arrived. The result was a reversal of their previous autumn's Tenno Sho meeting, where Bubble Gum Fellow had finished first and Marvelous Sunday fourth. Over another 200 metres, on a different course, their order changed. It was an active rivalry between high-class horses, rather than a champion and a permanent supporting player.
At Tokyo on 26 October, Yukio Okabe was back aboard for the defence of the Tenno Sho. Bubble Gum Fellow started favourite, ahead of Air Groove. The mare won by a neck in 1:59.0, and the gap behind the pair was five lengths to Genuine. Royal Touch was another nose away in fourth. Those margins distinguish a closely fought defeat from a merely respectable placing. Air Groove and Bubble Gum Fellow had separated themselves decisively from the rest of this field.
The race also linked two horses whose Classic years had taken different forms. Air Groove had won the 1996 Oaks; Bubble Gum Fellow had missed the spring Classics altogether. Both were four by modern age reckoning when they met here, although the original chart calls them five. Air Groove carried 56 kilograms and he carried 58, as the detailed JRA result records. The mare's allowance was part of the championship conditions. The result establishes her victory under those conditions, without requiring an imaginary rematch at equal weights.
A champion before the missing Classics
Bubble Gum Fellow had been born on 11 April 1993 at Shadai Farm in Chitose, Hokkaido. He raced for Shadai Race Horse and was trained at Miho by Kazuo Fujisawa. His JBIS pedigree joins the American-bred Sunday Silence to Bubble Company, a French-bred daughter of Lyphard. The Japanese-born colt brought those two imported lines together at a time when Sunday Silence's early Japanese crops were establishing an extraordinary new presence.
There was already international achievement on the maternal side. The Japanese breeders' association's profile identifies Candy Stripes as a half-brother, and records his later Argentine sire championship. Bubble Gum Fellow's own racing identity was Japanese, but the family could not usefully be understood as an isolated domestic creation. The sire and dam had arrived from different racing countries, while a son of the same mare had already carried the family's influence into another breeding population.
Okabe rode Bubble Gum Fellow in all four starts of his juvenile season. Third on debut over 1,800 metres at Tokyo on 7 October 1995, he returned to win another newcomers' race over the same course and distance on 29 October. The repeated race category is a feature of the contemporary record: a defeated newcomer could appear in another such contest. He then won the Fuchu Sansai Stakes, again over 1,800 metres, before shortening to a mile for the Asahi Hai Sansai Stakes on 10 December.
At Nakayama he beat Eishin Guymon by three-quarters of a length in 1:34.2 on firm turf, with Generalist third. The race was then held at Nakayama, and its old name used Japan's former age convention. These were two-year-olds in today's terminology. His award was recorded at the time as Best Three-Year-Old Colt; modern databases normalise it to Best Two-Year-Old Colt. Keeping that distinction makes the juvenile title and the later three-year-old Tenno Sho victory fit the same chronology.
On 24 March 1996 he extended his winning sequence to four in the Spring Stakes over 1,800 metres. Cheers Silence was second. A juvenile champion with a successful trial behind him had an obvious claim on the Classics, but a fracture discovered before the Satsuki Sho ended that spring campaign. He did not run in either the Satsuki Sho or the Japanese Derby. The absence belongs in his assessment: there is no Classic defeat to explain away and no basis for awarding him a hypothetical Classic victory.
The alternative Fujisawa actually chose
The autumn offered a choice between races with very different demands. The Kikuka Sho was the three-year-olds' 3,000-metre Classic. The Tenno Sho at Tokyo was a mixed-age championship over 2,000. According to the Japanese JRA-VAN retrospective, Fujisawa judged that distances up to 2,000 metres suited Bubble Gum Fellow best and selected the Tenno Sho route. That account supplies a specific sporting reason for the decision. Missing the spring did not oblige the stable to recover its Classic season by attempting the longest remaining Classic.
The programme permitting this decision was relatively recent. JRA's history of the Tenno Sho records the autumn distance reduction from 3,200 to 2,000 metres in 1984, followed by the admission of three-year-olds in 1987. These were separate reforms. One created a middle-distance championship; the other allowed the younger generation into it. By 1996 Fujisawa could choose a race suited to his assessment of the colt, even though the opposition would be older and more established.
This is the proper boundary around Bubble Gum Fellow's frequently repeated historical distinction. He was the first three-year-old to win the autumn Tenno Sho after the 1987 opening of the modern race to that age group. That wording concerns a defined set of conditions, rather than treating the entire history of the Emperor's Prize as one unchanged competition. It also explains why his achievement was more than an unusually early victory in an older horse's race: he had made a comparatively new route work at the highest level.
His return came in the Mainichi Okan on 6 October. Over 1,800 metres at Tokyo, Okabe rode him to third behind Annus Mirabilis, two tenths of a second behind the winner. The official career record places that race more than six months after the Spring Stakes. It was a single preparation against older horses before the championship. He arrived with recent evidence that he could compete, but with nothing like a full autumn campaign already behind him.
October 1996: close enough to strike
The Tenno Sho on 27 October assembled Sakura Laurel, Mayano Top Gun and Marvelous Sunday among seventeen runners. Sakura Laurel had won the spring Tenno Sho; Mayano Top Gun brought a record that included the previous year's Kikuka Sho and Arima Kinen. Bubble Gum Fellow was third favourite, behind Laurel and Marvelous Sunday. This was a serious vote of confidence in a younger horse returning from a broken spring, even though he was not the public's first choice.
Ebina took the ride in place of Okabe and kept Bubble Gum Fellow third through the recorded turns. Mayano Top Gun followed in fifth, Marvelous Sunday was farther behind, and Sakura Laurel came from still farther back. The individual JRA figures credit the winner with an estimated final 600 metres of 34.5 seconds, against 34.4 for Mayano Top Gun, 34.1 for Laurel and 34.2 for Marvelous Sunday. He beat horses who finished their last section faster because he had occupied a more advanced position before that section began.
My reading of those figures is that his ability included making a sustained challenge from close enough to the lead. The result was not a demonstration of the field's fastest isolated closing sprint. He won in 1:58.7 on firm turf, half a length ahead of Mayano Top Gun, with Laurel a neck behind the runner-up and Marvelous Sunday another head away. Bubble Gum Fellow carried 56 kilograms against their 58, the age allowance under the race's conditions. Position, finishing effort and the terms of the race all belong in the explanation.
For Ebina it was a first JRA Grade 1 victory, as the Japanese retrospective confirms. For Fujisawa it vindicated the choice of an older-horse middle-distance target. The two milestones were achieved together, but neither requires a claim that the colt had been overlooked or that the opposition was weak. He was a well-supported contender who beat three major rivals in a close finish after a preparation tailored to this race.
The extra distance, and a second chance at Tokyo
The following Japan Cup produced the one conspicuous failure in his thirteen-start career. On 24 November 1996 he finished thirteenth behind Singspiel, three seconds behind the winner over 2,400 metres. It was his first attempt beyond 2,000. The result was consistent with caution about extending him, but a single poor race cannot isolate distance from every other aspect of preparation and performance. His second Japan Cup would supply an important correction to any absolute claim that he could not compete over the trip.
First he returned at Hanshin in the Naruo Kinen on 15 June 1997. This was a Grade 2 over 2,000 metres at the time. Carrying 59 kilograms under Okabe, he beat Tokai Taro by two lengths in 2:01.4. The summer Takarazuka second followed three weeks later. He then won the Mainichi Okan on 5 October, again carrying 59, this time over 1,800 metres at Tokyo. The two wins bracketed his narrow championship defeat and restored a firm foundation for the autumn.
After Air Groove beat him in the Tenno Sho, they met again in the Japan Cup on 23 November. Bubble Gum Fellow was favourite. Pilsudski won by a neck from Air Groove in 2:25.8, with Bubble Gum Fellow a length and a quarter behind her in 2:26.0. Caitano was fourth. The mare had beaten him again, but he had also improved from a distant thirteenth to third in the same international championship over the same distance.
The race developed quietly at first: the published 200-metre sections add up to 60.8 seconds for the opening kilometre, and the final 600 took 35.1. Bubble Gum Fellow travelled near Air Groove in the forward group, with Pilsudski farther back in the early corner order. These are race-level splits, not a reconstruction of the colt's individual kilometre. They show why the 1997 performance is useful evidence of competitive range without proving that 2,400 metres was his ideal assignment. He could contend in this particular longer championship, while his victories remained concentrated between a mile and 2,000 metres.
A stallion's work beyond the championship circuit
That Japan Cup was his final start. His racing registration was removed on 15 January 1998, the date in JRA's career file, and he entered stud at Shadai Stallion Station. He finished with seven wins from thirteen starts, five graded victories and two Grade 1s. The two wins at the highest level came at two and three; his four-year-old season supplied two more graded wins and three championship placings. It is a compact career in which the evidence for continued class extends beyond the last G1 trophy.
His breeding opportunity was substantial. The JBIS covering record lists 128 mares in 1998, 161 in 1999, 182 in 2000 and 209 in 2001. These are mares covered, not foals born or winners produced. Later he stood at Breeders' Stallion Station. A Japanese report of its February 2009 parade places him among an establishment whose stallions had recently supplied important winners, specifically drawing attention to his son Early Robusto. This is a contemporary view of an active breeding career, rather than a retrospective judgement based only on whether he replaced his sire at the top of the rankings.
Two sons illustrate the spread of that work. Appare Appare won the 2002 Nagoya Grand Prix over 2,500 metres on dirt, with Yutaka Take riding. Early Robusto won the 2009 Keisei Hai over 2,000 metres on turf, beating Nakayama Festa by a neck under Yuichi Fukunaga. The first result belongs to the exchange circuit joining central and regional racing; the second belongs to the preparation season for JRA's three-year-old Classics. A turf middle-distance sire could contribute to both, without every offspring reproducing his own preferred surface or route.
Bubble Gum Fellow died on 26 April 2010, aged seventeen, from pneumonia. In the report carrying the JRA announcement, a representative of the breeders' club described persistent fever from March, a diagnosis at Shadai Horse Clinic in early April, and the suspension of covering duties while he received treatment. His life ended at the stud, years after the narrow finishes at Tokyo. For understanding the racehorse, those finishes remain especially valuable: the younger colt found a new championship route, and the older horse remained close enough to its leading figures to make them earn their victories.